2012 Porsche Cayman

Change year or car

Change year or car

$51,900

starting MSRP

2012 Porsche Cayman

Key specs

Base trim shown

Overview

The good:

  • Intuitive responses
  • Handling balance
  • 3.4-liter six-cylinder's performance
  • Accommodating cabin
  • Gas mileage

The bad:

  • Manual shifter feel
  • Price tag warrants more luxurious interior
  • Overhead stoplights can be hard to see

4 trims

Starting msrp listed lowest to highest price

Wondering which trim is right for you?

Our 2012 Porsche Cayman trim comparison will help you decide.

Notable features

  • New lightweight Cayman R
  • Final model year for this generation
  • Mid-engine design
  • Choice of flat-six-cylinder engines
  • Front and rear cargo areas

2012 Porsche Cayman review: Our expert's take

By Mike Hanley

The verdict:

Versus the competiton:

Car enthusiasts often deride mainstream, popular cars as “appliances,” saying they don’t offer any driving fun. In most cases they’re right, but that doesn’t mean those cars aren’t what most people want.

The 2012 Porsche Cayman R, on the other hand, is not an appliance; driving it is like piloting an oversized go-kart, and it offers one of the best blends of power and handling for the money.

The 2012 Porsche Cayman base starts at $52,850 (including a $950 destination charge), but the lightweight Cayman R version we tested, which is new for 2012, is considerably more expensive, at $67,250. In between there’s the Porsche Cayman S, which uses a slightly less powerful version of the Cayman R’s flat-six engine. Click here to see the Cayman S and Cayman R trim levels compared side-by-side, or see how the Cayman R’s specs stack up against comparable sports cars — the Audi TT RS and the Lotus Evora — here.

Styling
The first-generation 
Porsche Cayman enters its seventh model year for 2012. Porsche Cayman due for a redesign in the near future, but the current car can still turn heads, especially the Porsche Cayman S and Cayman R trims. It has its own look distinct from Porsche’s iconic 911, and in some ways it’s a more graceful one. The mid-engine design facilitates a low hood bordered by elliptical bi-xenon headlight assemblies, and the roofline trails gently toward the rear of the coupe.

Perhaps more likely to elicit strong opinions is the available Peridot Metallic paint, which our test car had. It’s an intense shade of green, but the black Porsche graphics on the doors and the optional black-painted 19-inch wheels made for an eye-pleasing contrast.

Extension of the Driver
It’s a description that’s overused whenever sports cars are discussed, but the Cayman R can legitimately be called an extension of the driver. Its responses are that intuitive, its transitions that natural and balanced. It’s easy to feel connected to the Cayman R in a way most sports cars can’t match.

Different elements of the driving experience contribute to this sensation, but it starts with the steering. The setup is amazingly natural, free of excess power assistance that can get in the way of steering feedback. Porsche has done an excellent job making it seem like there aren’t many components separating the steering wheel from the front wheels, and this is key to how it feels in your hands — whether cornering or going in a straight line.

The Porsche Cayman’s front-to-rear weight distribution is another important element. With the car’s mid-engine layout, Porsche has achieved a 45/55 weight distribution, front/rear. The car isn’t hauling around a lot of weight, either, especially in R form: It weighs 2,855 pounds, 121 less than the Cayman S, which means you get an exception power-to-weight ratio. Beyond that, the center of gravity feels especially low. The rear-wheel-drive Porsche Cayman R’s ride height is lower than the base Cayman or the Cayman S; it uses an exclusive suspension that drops the car about an inch.

All this combined lets you tackle corners with an enthusiasm that would have other cars begging you to slow down. The Cayman R, by comparison, begs you to go faster. You really have to recalibrate your sense of maximum permissible cornering speeds — its capabilities are that high.

Flat-Six Fun
Perhaps the only downside of the Cayman R’s 330-horsepower, 3.4-liter flat-6-cylinder engine is that you can’t see it unless the car is on a lift. The engine is covered by a parcel shelf behind the two sport bucket seats, and the only visual cue that there’s an engine underneath is a small access panel.

There are, however, plenty of auditory reminders that there’s a horizontally opposed six-cylinder under the shelf, especially when you stand on the gas pedal; the engine lets out a mechanical symphony when the tachometer needle swings to 4,000 rpm or so. The engine pulls strongly even at highway speeds, quickly adding 10 mph to your cruising speed. Porsche cites a zero-to-60-mph time of 4.7 seconds with the six-speed manual transmission and 4.6 seconds with the optional dual-clutch automatic known as PDK.

Instead of the PDK, our test car had the manual, and while the shifter has short throws that make quick shifts easy, shift feel lags behind the high expectations set by the rest of the car. Whereas everything else related to the driving experience exudes precision and exactness, the shifter feels a little vague and muddy as you row it through the gears.

The Sport Chrono Package includes an analog stopwatch on the dashboard and a Sport button that makes throttle response much more immediate. It also raises the rev-limiter and activates the optional sport exhaust. In a car like the Cayman R, Sport mode would be a good starting point for the drivetrain settings, as opposed to an optional one; the normal mode’s more relaxed tuning doesn’t go as well with the car, but it improves efficiency and keeps PDK-equipped cars running at a quieter engine speed.

For a performance car, the Cayman R’s EPA-estimated gas mileage is quite good. It’s rated at 19/27 mpg city/highway with the manual transmission. With the automatic, fuel economy estimates improve to 20/29 mpg. Premium gas is required.

The Inside
Despite its compact exterior, the 
Porsche Cayman R’s cabin can accommodate taller drivers. I’m 6-foot-1, and I was comfortable in the driver’s seat. The bucket leather seats are firmly cushioned and have considerable side bolsters that hold you in place in corners.

We’ve seen Porsche improve its interior quality in recently redesigned models like the Cayenne SUV and the 911, but the current-generation Cayman predates those models by a number of years. As such, the car’s interior is decent — with good fit-and-finish and materials quality — but it’s not especially luxurious considering its near-$53,000 starting price.

Besides contributing to the Cayman R’s handling prowess, the car’s mid-engine layout results in two trunks. The one in front is deep and measures 5.3 cubic feet, and the parcel shelf under the rear hatch is 9.2 cubic feet. If you use soft-sided bags you can fit a surprising amount of luggage in the car.

Safety
Like many other sports cars, the Cayman hasn’t been crash-tested by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety or the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

Standard safety equipment includes antilock brakes and an electronic stability system, both of which are required on new vehicles as of the 2012 model year. The Cayman also has seat-mounted side-impact airbags and side curtain airbags that deploy upward from the doors.

For a full list of safety features, check out the Features & Specs page.

Cayman in the Market
The 
Porsche Cayman is something of an overlooked gem in the Porsche lineup. It’s consistently outsold by its drop-top sibling, the Boxster, as well as the pricier 911. Sales aside, it remains my favorite Porsche sports car for daily driving. The car’s secret is that its modern technology doesn’t get in the way of driving engagement, but rather enhances it. That’s one of the reasons the Porsche Cayman landed on our list of fun-to-drive cars.

The next-generation Cayman, which we expect to be less than a year away, will probably take many cues from the recently redesigned 2013 Boxster. Even though the Porsche Cayman has been around for a while in its current form, the car is as appealing as ever and a perfect country-road companion. Rejoice, car enthusiasts, rejoice.

Send Mike an email  

 

Consumer reviews

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Comfort 4.7
  • Interior design 5.0
  • Performance 5.0
  • Value for the money 4.5
  • Exterior styling 4.8
  • Reliability 5.0

Most recent consumer reviews

4.9

Cayman R

The Cayman R is amazing on all levels. The R handles like a race car but is soft enough for the street. The mid-engine configuration (which is also leveraged by the factory Porsche race team for their GTLM entries) is superior. This car will be a collectable very soon as only 461 made it to the US.

5.0

Most exciting and beautiful car to own

Never though I could feel this way. I found a perfect traveling companion, always eager to please, gives unerringly whenever asked and does so unfailingly. Easy on the eye, passers by stare at her beauty. Graced with power, intelligence and a commanding presence with a softness within that belies her strength. Cayman S. Mine forever!

5.0

Awesome ride

This is by far the best handling car I've ever had. It's really quick and looks amazing. The sports option is worth the extra money.

See all 4 consumer reviews

Warranty

New car and Certified Pre-Owned programs by Porsche
Certified Pre-Owned program benefits
Maximum age/mileage
13 Years/124,000 miles
Basic warranty terms
2 years/unlimited miles after new-car limited warranty expires or from the date of sale if the new vehicle limited warranty has expired
Powertrain
2 years/unlimited miles after new-car limited warranty expires or from the date of sale if the new vehicle limited warranty has expired
Dealer certification required
111-point inspection
Roadside assistance
Yes
View all cpo program details

Have questions about warranties or CPO programs?

Compare the competitors

2009

Honda S2000

$34,995

starting MSRP

2020

BMW M2

$58,900

starting MSRP

2010

Porsche Boxster

$47,600

starting MSRP